Oh! Rings

Jul 13, 2026

On November 4, 1998, a Cessna 210L departed Bozeman, Montana, with five men aboard and full tanks. The plan was straightforward: a 700-nautical-mile ferry flight to San Carlos, California — well within the aircraft’s range. Four hours and forty-eight minutes later, sixty miles short of the destination, the engine went silent. The pilot switched tanks and tried to restart. Nothing. He turned back toward an airport they’d passed, but the airplane was already descending too fast. It struck trees and came to rest in a dry riverbed. The fuselage caught fire. The four passengers pulled each other from the wreckage, badly injured. The pilot died two weeks later.

Post-accident teardown found no mechanical failure in the engine itself. What investigators found instead was a leaking nose seal on the engine-driven fuel pump, damaged by corrosion and oxidation. That single seal — a small ring of rubber on the pump’s drive shaft — had been quietly bleeding fuel overboard at three to four gallons per hour throughout the entire flight. The crew had been flying on math that no longer applied to their airplane.

On October 17, 2022, a Mooney M20J departed Luskintyre, Australia, on what should have been an uneventful flight. It didn’t get far. Shortly after takeoff, a fire broke out in the engine compartment. The pilot attempted to return, but the situation deteriorated rapidly. The airplane struck terrain and was destroyed in a post-impact fire.

The Australian Transport Safety Bureau traced the origin of the fire to something almost insultingly small: an O-ring seal on the outlet fitting of the engine-driven fuel pump. The seal had deteriorated with age, allowing fuel to leak, vaporize, and ignite in the engine compartment. The O-ring had likely been in service for decades — possibly nearly three — without ever being disturbed. It hadn’t failed all at once. It had simply aged, hardened, and lost its ability to seal.

Two elastomeric seals. Two accidents. Both preventable.

A Brief History of O-Rings

The O-ring is one of the simplest mechanical components in existence — a torus of elastomeric material that seals a joint by being compressed between two surfaces. In theory, nothing could be more reliable. In practice, the wrong material, the wrong age, or the wrong installation technique turns an O-ring into a liability.

For most of general aviation’s history, the workhorse seal material was nitrile rubber, more commonly known by trade names like Buna-N or NBR (acrylonitrile-butadiene rubber). Nitrile is inexpensive, widely available, and reasonably compatible with petroleum-based aviation fuels. It was the natural choice for carburetors, fuel strainers, selector valves, gascolators, and fuel pump housings on generations of piston aircraft.

But nitrile has real limitations. Its maximum continuous service temperature sits around 212°F — acceptable for most GA applications but marginal in turbocharged engine compartments where temperatures regularly exceed that threshold. More importantly, nitrile ages. It oxidizes, hardens, and loses elasticity over time, even when sitting on a shelf. For that reason, military specifications historically required “age control” — meaning nitrile O-rings had to be used within a specified number of years from their cure date and discarded when they aged out, regardless of appearance. A nitrile O-ring that looks fine on the bench may already be too far gone to seal reliably under thermal cycling and vibration.

In the 1950s, DuPont introduced Viton, a fluorocarbon elastomer the engineering world now classifies generically as FKM or FPM. Viton was developed specifically for aerospace applications and represented a significant leap forward: temperature capability up to roughly 400°F, far superior chemical resistance, and better resistance to compression set — the tendency of a seal to take a permanent “squish” and lose its ability to recover and reseal. Newer-generation FKM seals are now standard in many aircraft engine and fuel system applications, largely supplanting nitrile wherever heat and aggressive chemical environments are a concern.

The newest kid on the block — and the material that deserves more attention in piston GA — is fluorosilicone, known chemically as FVMQ. Fluorosilicone combines the fuel and chemical resistance of a fluorocarbon with the wide temperature range of silicone rubber. It retains flexibility at temperatures down to -65°F, where both nitrile and FKM can become brittle. Critically, fluorosilicone carries no shelf-life limitation — you can store a bag of aviation-grade fluorosilicone O-rings for fifteen years and install them with full confidence.

Identifying O-ring material in service is tricky, since seals seldom carry markings. As a rough rule of thumb, older black O-rings are often Buna-N/nitrile, brown ones are commonly Viton/FKM, and blue or green seals in fuel system applications are frequently fluorosilicone/FVMQ. These color conventions are not standardized, however, and none should be relied upon for positive identification. The age of a seal may be a more reliable indicator than its color.

SIDEBAR: O-Rings and Unleaded Avgas

Why Seals Fail

Elastomers live a tough life. Exposed to heat, oxygen, fuel, oil, and constant compression, the polymer chains that give the material its elasticity gradually break down or cross-link, making the material stiffer and less resilient.

One of the most common failure modes is compression set: the O-ring takes on a permanent flattened shape and no longer pushes firmly against the sealing surfaces. It may still appear intact, but it’s no longer doing its job. A seal may weep slightly for a long time before it leaks enough to be noticed — and in a fuel system, vapor accumulation in unseen places is a hazard in its own right. The ATSB made a point in its Mooney report worth emphasizing: the absence of a visible leak during inspection doesn’t mean a seal will perform under all operating conditions.

Replace Everything?

It’s tempting to think the solution is simple: replace every old O-ring with a new one made from better material. But the decision isn’t cost-free.

Every time you open a fuel or oil system, you create an opportunity for a maintenance-induced failure. Fittings get loosened and retightened. Seals can be nicked, twisted, or improperly lubricated. Torque values can be wrong. A connection that was working fine can suddenly develop a leak after reassembly, and the damage may not be visible on inspection. The decision to replace a seal that isn’t causing problems should not be taken casually.

The competing risks are real: leave an aging seal in place and it may eventually fail on its own terms; disturb a stable system and you may create the very problem you were trying to prevent. The right answer depends on the circumstances.

SIDEBAR: Is Upgrading O-Rings Legal?

A Thoughtful Approach

The most defensible strategy is opportunistic replacement. Whenever a component must be removed for another reason — when the system is already open — that’s the ideal time to replace its seals with modern materials. No additional maintenance-induced failure risk is incurred, and the benefit of installing current-generation fluorosilicone or FKM is real.

Beyond that, judgment is required. A seal that has been undisturbed for years, shows no sign of leaking, and sits in a relatively benign location may be best left alone. But not all seals live in benign locations. Firewall-forward, a seal failure can cause an in-flight fire. In high-consequence locations, if there is evidence — or even reasonable suspicion — that seals are decades old and have never been replaced, prophylactic action is warranted even if nothing appears to be leaking.

Dynamic seals deserve separate consideration. The shaft seal of a rotary fuel pump or fuel selector valve is subject to constant wear regardless of material and should be replaced on a schedule, not just when something starts leaking.

When seals are replaced, technique matters as much as the decision to replace them. Proper lubrication, careful handling, correct sizing, and meticulous assembly are essential. An improperly installed new seal can be worse than an aging one that was working.

The two accidents that opened this column weren’t the result of complex failure sequences. They were caused by small elastomeric seals that had been in service too long. Old seals have a tendency to retire themselves — on their own schedule, at altitude, at a time of their choosing

SIDEBAR: O-Rings and Unleaded Avgas

The transition from 100LL to unleaded avgas adds a new dimension to the O-ring material question. 100LL’s heavy aromatic content has always caused nitrile rubber to swell slightly in service. That swell was a feature, not a bug: it kept nitrile O-rings pressed firmly against their mating surfaces. The three leading unleaded avgas candidates, however, take very different chemical approaches to replacing tetraethyl lead’s octane contribution, and those differences pull in opposite directions for fuel system elastomers.

GAMI’s G100UL achieves its octane through a high-aromatic formulation. Its aromatic load is more chemically aggressive than typical 100LL’s, which is why G100UL has been associated with paint staining and elastomer compatibility warnings from Cirrus, Lycoming, and others since its California rollout in late 2024. (Note: The FAA has evaluated all of those OEM warnings and has not, to date, identified any safety of flight issue.)

For aircraft running G100UL, the concern with nitrile seals isn’t shrinkage — it’s “swelling”. GAMI’s STC for G100UL explicitly states that when replacing seals and O-rings the mechanic should use components made of silicone or fluoropolymer elastomers (such as Viton) where practical. The same applies to fuel hoses: when replacing flexible fuel hose assemblies, use tetrafluoroethylene (Teflon) lined hose assemblies per TSO C53a or TSO C140 where practical. Note, the STC does not require those components to be changed prior to use of G100UL Avgas, but guides owners and mechanics to upgrade fuel-wetted components on a timely basis where practical.

Swift’s 100R and the LyondellBasell/VP Racing UL100E go the other direction, using ETBE (ethyl tert-butyl ether) as their octane booster. These fuels are low-aromatic, and it’s here that the nitrile shrinkage concern applies. An aircraft transitioning from 100LL to an ETBE-based fuel may find that nitrile seals swelled into service over the years are now undersized for the job.

Fluorosilicone holds up well across all of these scenarios. It maintains dimensional stability across a wide range of fuel chemistries — neither swelling aggressively in high-aromatic fuels nor shrinking in low-aromatic ones. Whatever ends up in your tanks in 2030, a fluorosilicone O-ring won’t care.

SIDEBAR: Is Upgrading O-Rings Legal?

One question that inevitably comes up is whether substituting a modern seal material for the original Buna-N or legacy Viton is even legal. Material substitution is governed by 14 CFR 43.13(b), which requires the use of materials of such quality that the condition of the product worked on will be at least equal to its original or properly altered condition.

If replacing a Buna-N or legacy Viton O-ring with a fluorosilicone or modern FKM equivalent does not affect fit, form, or function — and does not degrade safety — it can typically be treated as a minor alteration documented with a simple logbook entry, using acceptable data such as AC 23-27 (Parts and Materials Substitution for Vintage Aircraft). AC 23-27 is intended primarily for older, legacy GA aircraft — generally those certificated prior to about 1980 under CAR 3 or early Part 23 — where original materials or parts may be unavailable, obsolete, or less than optimal. The vast majority of the piston GA fleet qualifies as “vintage” under this definition.

Note that if the seal is part of a certificated appliance (such as a fuel servo, pump, or other PMA/TSO component), material substitution may not be appropriate without manufacturer guidance or approved data. For example, a decades-old service bulletin on the RSA fuel servos used in fuel-injected Lycoming engines called for replacing nitrile diaphragms with modern materials. Cessna did the same thing for fuel systems in twin Cessnas. If your aircraft has GAMI’s G100UL STC, its installation instructions provide FAA approval to substitute newer seal and hose materials. As always, the mechanic approving the work is responsible for determining that the substitution is airworthy, compatible, and properly documented.

Free Guide

The Six Most Common Blunders Aircraft Owners Make Managing Their Aircraft Maintenance.